▲
1
▼
"It was decided that Kraid was not imperative enough to the Metroid Prime project to run the risk of pushing up the release date in order to fit him in." -Gene Kohler
▲
2
▼
According to one of the game's tech leads Jack Mathews, shortly after Metroid Prime shipped, Nintendo told Retro Studios that a "bad batch" of GameCube CPUs shipped, and apparently this game was the only game that misbehaved on them. Upon seeing videos of the issue, it became clear to them what was going on:
In retrospect, he wondered if it was possible to instead rig up the GameCube so it stayed in the freezer and let the wires run out to connect to the TV to save time running back and forth.
On the more technical side, Mathews explained:
When a player called Nintendo of America's support hotline about this animation problem, they would send them a new copy of the game disc with this updated code.
When this story was posted to Twitter in 2022, one user posted an older video of a graphics glitch positing that the issue is "caused by the ANCS file using the wrong CSKR for the suit model", and that it might be possible to simulate the issue outside of the hardware and software conditions it originally happened in. Mathews replied:
Mathews also talked about how it would have been a bigger hassle to rewrite the skinning pipeline to use the locked cache, because it would have been a rewrite by taking the risk of adding new code and may have net slowed things down. Adding the NOPs wouldn't break anything and just moved the stalls from the memory controller to the PPC chip.
"All animated objects were freaking out... we needed to actually slow down some of our code, because it was running too fast for these CPUs to handle! We needed to be able to test this, but Nintendo only had one dev kit with this CPU. We couldn't detect the CPU, and if we slowed it down too much, the game's framerate would tank. If we didn't slow it down enough, it would glitch. Even worse, we had to burn disks for this kit. So each test was hours. Even weirder was to see the problem, the kit had to be cold. Like, freezer cold. So we literally had to put the kit in the freezer, test the game for 15 minutes tops, then start all over. It was crazy. We literally were running the kit from the break room freezer to the TV, and loading save games as fast as possible to as many places as possible in 15 minutes, then trying new code, re-freezing, and back. I'll never forget it."
In retrospect, he wondered if it was possible to instead rig up the GameCube so it stayed in the freezer and let the wires run out to connect to the TV to save time running back and forth.
On the more technical side, Mathews explained:
"Our skinning used the locked cache DMA to read in data and the write gather pipeline to write it out. Most of the Nintendo samples used the locked cache for both read and write, so my method was a bit faster. But it also hit memory bandwidth limits. As I recall, the issue was that the write gather pipe on these broken CPU's wouldn't stall when it was full or properly report its status, so we had to keep inserting NOPs in the code to slow it down just enough to stop stalls from happening, but not so much to slow down the game."
When a player called Nintendo of America's support hotline about this animation problem, they would send them a new copy of the game disc with this updated code.
When this story was posted to Twitter in 2022, one user posted an older video of a graphics glitch positing that the issue is "caused by the ANCS file using the wrong CSKR for the suit model", and that it might be possible to simulate the issue outside of the hardware and software conditions it originally happened in. Mathews replied:
"I don't know if it was writing out less than we were putting in the write-gather, or throwing away and reusing from the buffer, but sort of along these lines, with more jittering and triangles all over the place. This example has coherent skinning, just a bad mapping... I think the WG pipe was a 96 byte circular buffer. So when it wouldn't stall, it would write bytes over earlier entries in the buffer before they could flush to main memory. These would still be four-byte aligned writes, so I think the way to emulate it would be to take blocks of anywhere from 4-32 bytes (a multiple of four) and move them back by 96 bytes in the skinning buffer."
Mathews also talked about how it would have been a bigger hassle to rewrite the skinning pipeline to use the locked cache, because it would have been a rewrite by taking the risk of adding new code and may have net slowed things down. Adding the NOPs wouldn't break anything and just moved the stalls from the memory controller to the PPC chip.
Jack Mathews tweet:
https://twitter.com/jack_mathews/status/1590748677160566786
Older video of a graphics glitch:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5f-N9WUHJwE
https://twitter.com/jack_mathews/status/1590748677160566786
Older video of a graphics glitch:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5f-N9WUHJwE
▲
2
▼
Retro Studios received conflicting feedback from Nintendo of America and co-producer Shigeru Miyamoto. NoA asked them to switch to a first-person perspective, cut any two of the girls, and improve the remaining girl's controls, leaving Brynn as the sole protagonist. Miyamoto then told them that he felt Brynn was too generic of a protagonist and was uncertain about the game being a first-person shooter. From here, the team would switch back to third-person and completely rewrite the game. It now took place in the 1970's and starred an alien protagonist that the United States government had discovered in a crashed UFO. A government team called "MetaForce" then raised it as their own to combat another evil alien race planning to invade and enslave humanity. One day out of nowhere, Miyamoto commented that the game's new alien designs would make for great Space Pirates, and asked the developers if they would prefer to make a Metroid game instead. They agreed, and MetaForce was cancelled in favor of what would become Metroid Prime.
| keyboard_double_arrow_left keyboard_arrow_left | Page 2 of 2 | keyboard_arrow_right keyboard_double_arrow_right |
Related Games
Metroid
Metroid Prime: Trilogy
Metroid Prime 2: Echoes
Metroid: Samus Returns
Metroid: Zero Mission
Metroid Prime
Metroid Prime 2: Echoes
Metroid Prime Hunters
Metroid Prime 4: Beyond
Metroid Fusion
Metroid Prime 3: Corruption
Metroid
Metroid Prime: Federation Force
Super Metroid
Metroid Dread
Metroid: Other M
Metroid II: Return of Samus
Metroid Prime Remastered
Super Smash Bros. Brawl
Ultimate NES Remix
Super Smash Bros. for Wii U
Nintendo World Championships: NES Edition
Super Smash Bros. Melee
Famicom Mini Collection
Super Smash Bros. Ultimate
Super Smash Bros. for Nintendo 3DS
Super Smash Bros.
Super NES Classic Edition
NES Remix 2
Nintendo Land
Metroid II: Return of Samus DX
Illusion of Gaia
Mega Man 6
Zero: Tsukihami no Kamen
Pokémon Black Version
Ken Griffey Jr.'s Winning Run
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past & Four Swords
Fire Emblem Warriors: Three Hopes
Fire Emblem: Ankoku Ryuu to Hikari no Tsurugi
Pokémon: Let's Go, Eevee!
Giftpia
Kirby's Avalanche
Pikmin Bloom
Tetris
ActRaiser
StarTropics
Tetris & Dr. Mario
Pokkén Tournament
Donkey Kong: Coconut Crackers
Pikmin 4